Since the initial reveal of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, many have found it difficult to reconcile the younger version of Galadriel portrayed in the series with the character introduced in The Lord of the Rings—an iconic role played by Cate Blanchett. Critics argue that this new iteration strays from Tolkien’s original vision, perceiving it as a reimagining or even a dismissal of the source material. However, the latest episode of ScreenRant’s The Rings of Power Podcast delves into Tolkien’s unpublished writings to uncover the truth behind these interpretations.
When addressing the ongoing debate about the identity of The Stranger—whether he is Gandalf or a Blue Wizard—the concept of J.R.R. Tolkien’s ‘canon’ becomes much more fluid. Tolkien’s published works first introduced readers to Galadriel, but much of her backstory evolved over time, with later revelations coming from his expansive writings. He continuously enriched his original vision, drafting new chapters and altering his Silmarillion as his understanding of Galadriel’s character evolved. How do these insights compare to her depiction in The Rings of Power? The answers can be found in the current episode of The Rings of Power Podcast: “Young Galadriel’s Biggest Problem: Is She Based on Tolkien’s Version?”, linked below:
Hosts Andrew Dyce and Stephen Colbert explore Tolkien’s existing lore, examining the ideas and potential narratives he contemplated throughout his life, while also considering how the writers of The Rings of Power can creatively fill in the blanks. They highlight that the character of Galadriel had ample narrative potential before she became the wise figure who famously turned down the One Ring from Frodo.
Tolkien’s Complete Vision for Galadriel Aligns Remarkably with The Rings of Power
Unpublished Works Reveal an Arc for Galadriel That Mirrors the Show
The narrative surrounding Galadriel varies widely depending on which of Tolkien’s posthumously published writings are referenced. From her first appearance in The Fellowship of the Ring to the final days of Tolkien’s life, the notion of Galadriel’s ‘true’ story evolved continuously. Nevertheless, one aspect remained consistent: Tolkien envisioned Galadriel as the most brilliant, courageous, and extraordinary of all Elves in Middle-earth—and she was very much aware of this.
For those interested in diving deeper, the latest episode of The Rings of Power Podcast is available for listening above, and Tolkien’s Unfinished Tales provides further insights. Notably, Tolkien’s later works depict Galadriel as a powerful Elf driven by vengeance, her rage compelling her to leave Valinor for Middle-earth in pursuit of an enemy, ultimately determined to confront him, despite the darkness this quest cast upon her spirit. Although initially aimed at Feanor rather than Sauron, many thematic parallels can be drawn.
To engage in the full discussion and debate on this topic and more, make sure to follow The Rings of Power Podcast on your preferred podcast platform, and stay tuned to ScreenRant for continued coverage of season two and beyond.
